Blog

Reform Baby!

I am going to talk here about electoral reform, following our hung parliament result last year in the UK Elections.  There’s a poll at the bottom, so please tell me what you think…

Current System

We have a parliament with two “houses”, the House of Commons, and the House of Lords. The purposes of these two are slightly different. Generally, the House of Commons, made of nationally elected MPs, proposes laws, and then the House of Lords accepts, amends or blocks these laws. The two houses act as a check and balance on each other.

For election in the House of Commons, we currently have a system of First Past The Post (FPTP), which means there are a load of constituencies (650ish), and each one gets a clear winner, and the parliament is made up of these winners. Our House of Lords is currently selected by the Prime Minister, and approved by the Queen, with a little help from the parties, with a few bishops thrown in for good measure.

What’s wrong with it?

Firstly, the House of Commons has one big issue: FPTP. It is representative locally – you vote for your local MP – but you get no say nationally. I’ve drawn a graph below, that shows the number of seats each party won last election, contrasted with national percentage of the vote.

Clearly, this is lacking representativeness somewhere, since the Lib Dems got 23% of the vote, but less than 9% of the seats. So we probably need reform here.
Secondly, the House of Lords is undemocratic because none of us vote for it. Labour and Lib Dem both think we need elected Lords. Conservatives quite like the current system, because even those Lords elected by the other parties and Bishops and the like tend to be pretty conservative.

Since these figures are even more unbalanced, it could be argued that we probably need reform here too.

Making changes

So I think its clear that electoral reform could be a good idea. No one knows what’s best, there’s never going to be a consensus, but after a lot of debates with people about this (thanks Nick and Raj), and reading a lot of articles about it, I’ve made up my own mind.

The Lib Dems originally proposed using proportional representation. This means that, to an extent, a party that got 30% of the vote would get 30% of the seats (It’s not quite that simple, but its close enough for now). However, I have two concerns about PR:

Firstly, its not representative locally. Full PR would be that your vote counts nationally, but not locally. So the Tories get 40% of the vote, they go through and choose 40% of the MPs, from all their candidates. The problem with this is that if the voters that know a candidate best choose not to vote for him, his party may still choose to elect him.

The same applies with another type of PR: “Party list“, where your vote counts locally, but still not specifically. Here, a larger area is combined: so where there are currently 5 constiuencies, make it one big one, with one vote to cover all 5 MPs. The parties are listed, you vote for them, and again, if the Tories get 40% of the vote, they choose 2 of the 5 MPs on their own.

Another take on this is “Multi Member” (what the LDs apparently propose, although they are wonderfully vague about it), where you vote for individuals, rather than parties.  The concern is that it can still lead to voting on party lines, along larger constituencies with voters having less knowledge of individual candidates. Again meaning that the voters who know local candidates best would not have control.

Secondly, it is more likely to lead to a hung parliamentesque parties-making-deals situation. I’m not saying that’s definitely bad, but its also not necessarily good. In Ireland, for example, this has led to repeated weaker governments, of odd coalitions between parties that don’t agree on much. In Israel where they use PR, the average government only lasts 22 months. In Italy they’ve had about 60 different governments since 1945. Maybe this is a problem with countries that begin with “I”, or maybe its an issue with PR.

If we look at the best performing countries internationally, according to GDP, we are number 6 worldwide. And of the 5 countries above us: US, China, Japan, Germany and France; *none* uses a full PR system. Only Japan and Germany do a bit, with Japan using PR for 37.5% of seats, FPTP for the rest, and Germany using Mixed Member, which is a cross between PR and FPTP. In other words, of all these countries with strong economies, FPTP is the dominant system. What, would it appear, is the best option for us to take post recession?

There are many plus sides to proportionality: but I feel we should benefit from them in the House of Lords, not the House of Commons.

House of Commons logoThe House of Commons

I propose a single member STV system, with resized constituencies exactly the same size (also known as the Alternative Vote). What this means:

Local representation. Local people have a local say with a local MP. As mentioned above, PR would decrease this, and I feel it is pretty important – surely the best judge of a someone’s ability to represent the people are those who know them, rather than a selection based on what party they belong to?

Equal sizes. Ultimately, its fairer, because every MP is selected by exactly the same population size. There would be some exceptions to the resizing – the Isle of Wight would probably remain as one, rather than being 1.5 constituencies – but basically it would be fairer. This is what the government is proposing, albeit with reducing the number of MPs.

Your vote has more value. With single transferable vote, you put the candidates in order of how much you want them. So, if Spiderman, Hitler, James Bond and Chairman Mao were the candidates, you could vote:

  • James Bond 1
  • Spiderman 2
  • Chairman Mao 0
  • Hitler 0

This would mean that James Bond would get your vote. If he got knocked out, Spiderman gets it. If he gets knocked out, neither Hitler nor Chairman Mao get any help from you.

House of Lords logoThe House of Lords

It is claimed that part of the purpose of the House of Lords is to provide a “moral compass”; one of the reasons that there are 26 bishops as Lords. I think this is a difficult issue; a) how do we define UK morality, and b) is the House of Lords the correct place to impose it?

I am a practising Christian, and passionate about morality; but I don’t feel that bishops speak for me. I certainly don’t feel that the Church of England is a good example of “church”, let alone a righteous foundation to comment on the morals of a nation. More importantly, in a democratic system, should they be representing Muslims, Atheists and Jedis?

I feel that the best way to see good morals in government and law is to elect moral citizens to represent you. In other words; I have a higher chance of having a relationship with my local MP than any other MP or Lord. I therefore am more likely to be assured of his moral, ethical and professional conduct. He, is therefore, my choice for a “moral compass”.

Therefore, let’s have Lords elected by the exact proportion of the vote. Each party is given their percentage of votes at the national elections to propose Lords, with Lords elected for the length of the parliament; although many would presumeably continue through consecutive periods, if their party wished.

Conclusion

There we go. All on my own, I have perfectly solved the UK political reform dilemna: legislation being chosen by your locally elected parliament, and the nationwide passing of those decisions being done by a completely proportionally represented senate.

Except its never as easy as that, so tell me what you think in the poll, and leave an argumentative (or affirmative) comment below…

How to change the system?

What should we do to MPs

  • Alternative Vote - more local choice of MP, less proportional. (Also known as Single Transferable Vote) (34%, 12 Votes)
  • Multi member STV - less local choice of MP, more proportional. (29%, 10 Votes)
  • Shoot them all, and let the Queen run it! (17%, 6 Votes)
  • First Past The Post - Stay as it is. (14%, 5 Votes)
  • Full PR - no local choice at all, totally proportional. (6%, 2 Votes)

Total Voters: 35

Loading ...

What should we do to Lords?

  • Link it to percent of Vote: Lib Dems have 20% of votes, get 20% of Lords. (fully proportional) (68%, 17 Votes)
  • Stay as it is. (12%, 3 Votes)
  • Keep it chosen by the PM and Queen, but ditch the bishops. (tiny bit proportional) (12%, 3 Votes)
  • Ditch the Lords, and let Simon Cowell choose. (8%, 2 Votes)
  • Link it to number of MPs: Lib Dems have 20% of MPs, get 20% of Lords. (a bit proportional) (0%, 0 Votes)

Total Voters: 25

Loading ...

The waiting game

Kat was due to have our baby on Monday. Two days later, she still looks pretty fat, and I can’t see any soiled nappies anywhere, so I guess that hasn’t happened. This isn’t a new, or shocking phenomenon; first babies are often a week late – in some countries your due date for the first is 41 weeks rather than 40.

However, what’s weird for me is that the reality of the situation seems to be decreasing. For three weeks now, I’ve been going to work, expecting a call at any moment, “IT’S COMING!”, followed by a frantic dash back home, en route to the hospital.

Instead, nada. Every day that passes it feels less real. A week ago, I was like, “I’m literally going to have a son any moment”. Now, I’m more, “Is this actually going to happen?”

I can almost believe that the whole thing is going into reverse now, that the baby peaked, we missed our opportunity, and now its getting smaller again. I said this to Katherine yesterday, and then the midwife visited, telling her that the baby was smaller than last week! Apparently this was because he is curled up under her rib cage, and thus harder to measure… but I’m not so sure.

In other words, we may, or may not be having a baby this week. Beyond then, who can say?

Gift Appraisal

Christmas is a time where the phrase “It is more blessed to give than to receive” works rather well. Admit it – you absolutely cannot wait for your giftee to open that present. You’re on the edge of your seat, almost wanting them to open it before Christmas, just to get the tension out. They crinkle the wrapping paper, start to tear it open, and the whole experience is palpably enjoyable.

And then you open your own gifts, and all you got is socks and a book on koala conservation. I think maybe its the thrill of the hunt, more than the feeling of just getting more stuff. Anyway, I’m going to talk about my favourite Christmas presents now; both the ones I gave and recieved:

Giving

1. After the Storm

For Katherine Lowry

After the storm painting
This is a painting by Christine Tolman that we saw at the Epping Art Society Exhibition in December. We walked round the whole gallery, looked at every painting, and we were both blown away by this one. There’s something about the lighting, giving an effect more alive than a photo ever could convey.
(The image above doesn’t quite capture it – you’ll have to come round to experience it)

Rick Astley Tshirt2. Rick Astley tshirt

For Nick Lowry

If you’ve ever been rickrolled, you’ll understand the borderline obsession our generation has with the relational intent of Mr Rick Astley.

Sadly, despite his international acclaim for the YouTube hit, he has proven to be an unreliable boyfriend, as I found to my cost. If you like this tshirt, buy one. For each one sold, I’ll send Rick $1!

Square Photo Frames3. Picture Frames

For Katherine Lowry

In mid December, I went on a shopping trip with Katherine into Sheffield city centre. I was there for one thing: square picture frames. 4 hours later, Katherine had bought nearly all the presents for both sides of our extended family. I had failed to find a single shop selling 12″x12″ frames.

Frantically, I went online, and found a site selling them. It was sold out. I then found some on ebay, and purchased them. Only to discover that my paypal account had been frozen. And that the ebay seller was mega busy, and couldn’t post until after Christmas. Happily, I persevered, and eventually found them on eFrames.co.uk (for about £6 each), and got some photos printed to fit at LARprint.

4. Pass The Parcel

For Heze and Pudding

Our dogs have a deep and meaningful relationship with food. In the time I’ve had her, Heze has eaten (without permission): a huge plate of freshly cooked mince pies, tens of chocolate bars, Katherine’s dinner off the table twice, several whole tubs of butter and the majority of last night’s popcorn. Pudding is exactly the same, just more scared of us, and thus less likely to commit such blatant thefts. For Christmas, I made them a pass the parcel, a large, layered, newspaper wrapped bundle of dog treats around a new ball. They seriously enjoyed it.

Grandma's book5. Some Old Book

For Grandma

I’ll admit, I was not very involved in buying presents for Grandma. Or my Mum. Or my Dad. Or anyone except my brother and my wife. However, Katherine found a book on Birmingham architecture, and Grandma was really pleased with it.

I’m happy about that, because she generally feels like the family doesn’t care about her; its good to prove her wrong (even if, technically, you could argue that Katherine proved her wrong and I proved her right…)

Recieving

1. Table Football

From Katherine

Table football

OOOOOOOOOOOH YEEEEEAAAAAAH!!! This easily came in as my top present, partly due to the surprise: Kat pretended she had given me all my presents, and then left it half the day, before taking me on a walk down the road, to a friend’s empty house, where a fully wrapped table football table awaited me.

Once we got it set up in the cellar, we got a LOT of games under our belts over the Christmas period, including a tournament, which my Dad won, beating me in the final, and my mum barely escaped finishing last, with a 10-0 knockout in the first round, then a losers playoff against Grandad, which she won 1-0 (he scored an own goal).

Moka Pot 22. Moka Pot

From Elizabeth (sister-in-law)

You may remember that I recently became a convert to the world of coffee. Part of my enthusiasm came from the fun of operating a moka pot. I love the fun of putting the grounds in a moka pot, screwing it together, the water boiling, and steam bubbling into the top.

However, sometimes, I’m quite busy. On these occasions, I go upstairs for five minutes, to leave it to boil. A few months ago I did this, except I forgot to go downstairs. For about an hour. In that hour, the coffee boiled dry, then burnt, and the plastic handles completely melted off. It’s pretty cool to get a new one; here’s hoping I don’t go upstairs again.

hot sauce3. Chilli Sauce

From Nick (brother) and Amy (his girlfriend)

I quite like spicy food. My ideal food additive are jalepeno peppers. Just spicy enough to give food a kick, but not so much it burns your mouth, and with a wonderful flavour. On the other end of the spectrum is this bottle of hot sauce that my brother got me… Z Nothing Beyond.

Coming in at an SHU rating of 4,000,000 units (or 1600x hotter than jalepenos), its ridiculously hot. I mixed a load in with some chutney on Christmas day, and nearly killed Dad. So its good stuff. Tempted… why not watch a video of some idiots snorting it?

Reed Boat Book4. 8 Men and a Duck

From Mum

I’ve been a huge huge huge fan of the adventures of Thor Heyerdahl for many years; I think I first read about the Kon Tiki expedition when I was about 12. They are amazing, true life stories about an anthropologist with quirky ideas, and a commitment to a cause. I won’t say much more except that if you have a thirst for beauty, adventure and meaning, his books are perfect for you.

Anyway, I heard an interview on Radio 4 with Nick Thorpe a while back, where he talked about the adventure behind his book “8 Men and a Duck“. He, and 7 others (and a duck), all thoroughly unencumbered by maritime or navigational experience, built a reed boat, and sailed it 3,000 miles from South America to Easter Island. Needless to say, its a pretty wondrous book.

Its a wonderful life dvd5. Its a Wonderful Life

From Katherine

If you haven’t seen this film, you obviously haven’t truly experienced Christmas. I now own it on DVD, and, yes, I cried like a little girl at the end. Watch it!

One more coming…

I did actually get one more awesome present – a new keyboard. However, I’ll review that later this month, so that’s all for now.

Tell me: what were your favourite presents?

Deeper reverence

Just got back from church this morning, and one of the songs really spoke to me.

Now, those amongst you who grew up in the painfully religious churches of this land will probably be familiar with this particular monotonous dirge. However, if you can manage to shake off the memory of boredom from overlong services, and songs sung with a lack of passion that adequately mirrored the congregation’s engagement with God, the words of this song are pretty beautiful.

Take two minutes – actually read it:

Dear Lord and Father of mankind,
Forgive our foolish ways;
Reclothe us in our rightful mind,
In purer lives Thy service find,
In deeper reverence, praise.

In simple trust like theirs who heard,
Beside the Syrian sea,
The gracious calling of the Lord,
Let us, like them, without a word,
Rise up and follow Thee.

O Sabbath rest by Galilee,
O calm of hills above,
Where Jesus knelt to share with Thee
The silence of eternity,
Interpreted by love!

With that deep hush subduing all
Our words and works that drown
The tender whisper of Thy call,
As noiseless let Thy blessing fall
As fell Thy manna down.

Drop Thy still dews of quietness,
Till all our strivings cease;
Take from our souls the strain and stress,
And let our ordered lives confess
The beauty of Thy peace.

Breathe through the heats of our desire
Thy coolness and Thy balm;
Let sense be dumb, let flesh retire;
Speak through the earthquake, wind, and fire,
O still, small voice of calm.

Interestingly, it’s from a poem by JG Whittier, called “The Brewing of Soma“, where he talks about a load of druids getting wasted on hallucinogenic concoctions, and then realising that the only way to God is to live lives of peace, love and praise. One verse in the poem is thought to talk about the way Christianity sometimes concentrates too much on the other stuff rather than lifestyle and God:

As in that child-world’s early year,
Each after age has striven
By music, incense, vigils drear,
And trance, to bring the skies more near,
Or lift men up to heaven!

Whilst its a good point, I think there is a place for music, (expecially “trance“, or maybe drum ‘n bass…?), butit is important that quietness shouldn’t be forgotten.

All new and shiny

Blog screenshotNow Christmas is officially over, and since it is a New Year and all, I felt it was appropriate to rejig my blog. So, for your comfort and pleasure, notice several new additions…

New Theme

Based on the free Koi theme, from themify, with some fairly heavy alternations – new header anyone? I hope you like seeing my name burning up, if you want, you can learn how to do it yourself…

About

Finally, an about page on a website about me. Pretty poor that the blog hasn’t had one for a year (although there is one on the front page). Expect, at some point, a slightly longer autobiographical post added on.

Categories

Again, poor this hasn’t been here for so long. Find out about the many tangents I fall into, vaguely sorted into some kind of categories.

Adverts & Sponsors

You may notice a couple of adverts on the right hand side. I have a family to support: two dogs and a baby are not going to feed themselves. Please visit any of these sites that interest you, and you have a site you wish to promote, you may want to check out the sponsors page.

Contact

No longer do you have to leave a comment, hoping I’ll read it. Chuck me an email through the contact page – or just message @bigonroad on twitter!

Feedback appreciated, tell me what you love/hate in the comments…

Thoughts at New Years

At 10:30 on New Years Eve 2010, I was washing up. We had family round, and there were plates, and cups and bowls and spoons and tins and… lots to wash up. So I was in my little kitchen, in my little soapy zen zone, listening to the awesome New Years Eve mix on 6 Music.

I started thinking about how, actually, I was quite enjoying myself. This led to my first Resolution:

1. Spend more time with friends and family this year.

Then I realised that I was having way more fun than I do at work. That I would rather spend 40 hours a week washing up and listening to club classic interspersed with punk epics, than spend it caring for people as a doctor.

In reality, I can’t do this, and more importantly, I shouldn’t want to do this. Hence my second Resolution:

2. Start enjoying my job more.

And then I realised that I was on my laptop at 10:50 writing a blog post, feeling a bit low about life and careers and, the ultimate question – how to clean custard off a frying pan – when I should be next door beating my mother-in-law at Wii Mario Kart. Hence my third and final:

3. Stop complaining so much.

I’m off to enjoy the next year. Please invite yourself round to dinner if you haven’t seen me about, asking me about the world of Medicine, and tell me off if I complain!

Love you all!

PS. A brief glimpse of my soapy haven below…

A soapy haven from real life

Wireframe me up

Just found an fun new webapp called Wirify. Basically, you save it to your bookmarks, load a page you would like to see in wireframe, and click the link. It then gives you a wireframed version of your site.

Sadly, it doesn’t get it quite right for most of my sites. It’s based on jquery, so there are a few issues in how it sees components placed. For example, http://allaboutchris.co.uk:

Still, its an excellent tool for getting a quick idea, and you can always copy it into Fireworks and add the missing bits. Here’s http://saltandlightsolutions.com:

Wireframe of Salt and Light Solutions

So there you go. Wireframes made easy. Check out wirify at Volkside.com/2010/12/introducing-wirify-the-web-as-wireframes/.