Old King’s Crown tells the story of an ancient land where the King has gone missing, and you take on the role of pugnacious factions fighting amongst themselves for the throne. It’s a gorgeous, infuriating beast of a game, and quite unlike anything I’ve ever encountered.
The first thing that hits you before anything else is the art—this game is a work of intricate beauty. Every card has unique illustrations from designer Pablo Clark, and evocative in-world flavour text. Even the rulebooks look fabulous, and the approach to information management makes understanding the mechanics far easier than it could otherwise be. For example; each round of the game breaks into a year with four seasons, and the board faultlessly flows through these stages in a way that’s unmistakeable, and practically teaches itself.
The individual factions begin quite similar, but steadily become asymmetrical as time goes on. There’s elements of deck-building, tableau construction and engine building here; and it takes multiple plays to feel anywhere near close to fully understanding the options available to you. The rulebook gives some pointers—The Nobility, for example, favour “potent defence, the ability to sustain and exert control”—but ultimately, most strategy here is emergent and experiential.
Players begins with a deck of numbered faction cards. These have various suits on them, like quasi playing cards from an alternate history. Spring begins with players bidding faction cards face-down to claim advantageous kingdom locations. Bidding is a two-edged sword; bid high and you’ll win, but you’ll also tie up that faction card occupying locations for the rest of the game. Difficult choices define Old King’s Crown; you’re forced to sacrifice opportunities to pick any path, and each conceals myriad fatal mistakes.
Summer is the mountaintop moment; three grand battles take place on the board’s three regions. Using facedown faction cards, each player takes a stand. Winning a region means victory points and mechanical rewards, losing means nothing; or even having points stolen! The other three seasons are largely about increasing your strength and subterfuge during this stage, and revealing each set of cards is a moment charged with furious anticipation. When victory comes, when you’ve out-bluffed and out-manoeuvred your opponents? You truly do feel like you’ve won a kingdom. However, the downside is that you’ll lose too—often not through any fault of your own—and then it can feel your industriousness over the previous hour has been a waste of time.
I would be failing in my duty here if I didn’t warn you that there’s a pretty steep teaching experience ahead of you. I’ve yet to have the introductory teach last less than 40 minutes, and even then, the first game is mostly an introduction in itself. The rulebook teaching guide and starter deck couldn’t make this any easier, but it’s still a chunk of mental change, and the three-to-four hour play time doesn’t make the required multiple plays to understand all your cards (and everyone else’s) any more accessible.
This leads me to the most conflicted conclusion I’ve ever written. Old King’s Crown is a masterpiece. It’s exactly what it sets out to be, and I think it’s going to be on many shelves next to titles like War of the Ring, Agricola and Castles of Burgundy; an indisputable part of the pantheon of great games that define this glorious hobby. It’s just… there’s also an awful lot of people I play games with regularly who I wouldn’t recommend Old King’s Crown to. I’d teach them Root, which also has a complex introduction, beautiful aesthetics and asymmetric factions, but stops short of the—undeniably elegant—immensity of this wonderful game.
PLAY IT? MAYBE AND MUST PLAY
TTG’s first ever double rating? Old King’s Crown is a MUST-PLAY with a caveat. I’m not sure I’ve ever played a game that’s wormed into my brain in quite the same way. If you’re ready to establish yourself in this kingdom, it’s a crown that’s a pleasure to put on—but if you think that MAYBE sounds like too much commitment to actually be fun… well, heed your wariness, you may well be right.
TRY THIS IF YOU liked Root…
…For two such completely different games, there’s so much shared DNA here. Old King’s Crown hinges on the hidden; a bluffing, poker-school, whilst Root is a nuanced, riotous but ultimately simpler map-based power battle. Both have art to gush over, near endless replayability and the satisfaction of a unique faction board to call your own; both are a joy.
| About Old King’s Crown | |
|---|---|
| Designer | Pablo Clark |
| Publisher | Eerie Idol Games |
| Playcount | 1-4 Players |
| Age | Age 12+ |
| Price | £65 |
| Contents |
|
| Rating | Must Play |
A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2025.
