Button Shy games have been making dependably tiny games for years now. Their modus operandi is simple; 18 cards in a plastic wallet. You‘re most likely to have come across Sprawlopolis or Insurmountable, although their monthly club literally releases a new game every 30 days, so they have more titles than you can shake a stick at. Shallow Regrets is their latest release, in a friendly cross-over from Tettix Games’ Deep Regrets. Judson Cowan is the artist for both, and his illustrations have a cartoonish cosy-Cthulhu vibe that I can’t get enough of.
Now, you’d be right in thinking that it’s hard to make a particularly in-depth game with just 18 cards—but Button Shy’s genius is getting just enough crunchiness into an absolutely bite-sized package.
In Shallow Regrets, you are casting your net to pull out the best haul of fish cards. You begin with six stacks (or shoals) of cards, each with hints as to the size of fish on the back. Players pick two cards, but can only keep those with a difficulty equal-or-less than their current number of hooks. There’s an element of push-your-luck in picking a larger valued card; they can range from 3-5 hooks in cost—so you might have to throw them back if you can’t afford them, wasting your turn.
Half the cards are “fresh”, the other half are “foul”; whichever player has the most of those dark green foul cards at the end loses two points; a swing that’s often enough to change the winner. Those putrid picks can be powerful though, as they often have abilities that allow you to attack your opponents, or steal their cards. Once an ability is used, the card is exhausted.
Some fish have negative scores; the perfect play involves exhausting a particularly unpleasant rotten card, whilst using its ability to send it to your opponent, who is unable to return the favour as the ability is spent. Of course, your nasty-minded competitors are trying to do exactly the same thing as you, and picking up the rotten cards
Like most Button Shy creations, Shallow Regrets is fast to pick up, and a little lacking in depth, especially in the base experience. Their master stroke is that they tend to be great at building on those cores with mini expansions; I’ve tried out the Lingering Remorse add-on, which introduces six cards with permanent, re-usable abilities. Taking the deck from 18 to 24 significantly increases the strategic satisfaction—and I wouldn’t be surprise to hear they have more add-ons in the pipeline.
There’s also a solo expansion called The Fisher & The Frod, which does a decent job at emulating a real-life choice-making opponent. The Frod has its own abilities also, which means it’s playing a slightly different tactical game to you, and presents a puzzley alternate challenge to the multiplayer game.
Shallow Regrets doesn’t pretend to be anything more than it is; an enjoyable way to spend ten minutes hunting fish and slightly messing with your opponents. It also feels very similar in soul to Deep Regrets, probably making it a mandatory purchase for fans of the big sibling. For the rest of us, it’s worth a play, but you’ll probably find yourself yearning for deeper waters soon enough!
PLAY IT? YES
Charming, fast and fun, this is a palette-cleanser to play between bigger fish; or something simple to pass a few minutes with pals.
TRY THIS IF YOU liked Game of Trains
…
…Both are calm, card-based experiences that involve some gentle player interaction, take just a few minutes and look rather lovely into the bargain.
| About Shallow Regrets | |
|---|---|
| Designer | Judson Cowan |
| Publisher | Button Shy |
| Playcount | 1-3 Players |
| Age | Age 8+ |
| Price | £10 |
| Contents |
|
| Rating | Yes |
A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2025.
