Tales of the Old West review

“This table ain’t big enough for the both of us, Malone…”

Tales Of The Old West is a Wild West RPG, built on the same Year Zero engine that’s used to run Free League games like Alien and Tales From The Loop. Aiming to pull off some kind of game design trick-shot, the writers have set out to combine lightweight rules, historical accuracy (with a nod towards modern cultural sensitivities), all whilst retaining the guntotin’ freewheelin’ vibe of old Westerns! Do they pull this off? Perhaps surprisingly, the answer is a solid “Yeehaw!”

You begin in character creation, with two modes available, either picking an Archetype such as “Lawman” or “Grifter”, and selecting a number of Abilities and Talents, or using the fantastic Lifepath system at the end of the book, rolling an origin, a family, then a range of stages for your life. It’s nice to have both options, and both seem to work in crafting believable, balanced characters. My first character began as the son of a Mayor, got caught swindling as a Grifter, and became an Outlaw, eventually killing the gang lord terrorizing a small town and being elected Sheriff; a life moving full circle. It’s also more wide-ranging and culturally sensitive that you might expect—my second character was the child of an Iman from the Ottoman empire—and the authors have taken pains to include Indigenous and Diasporic peoples.

Attributes are broken down into four categories: Grit, Quick, Cunning and “Docity”; a semi-obsolete word meaning “speed of learning”, the usage of which appropriately peaked in 1880. Each then has four abilities, and in tests you combine both the Attribute and Ability score to build a dice pool. So, to fire your gun, you add your “Quick” and your “Shootin’” scores, and roll that many six-sided dice. Rolling at least one six counts as a success; extra ones are “stunts” which do extra damage, or give extra advantages in a situation.

This is all fairly standard for Year Zero; where Tales of the Old West fiddles with the formula is in the addition of Trouble dice and Faith points. Your first five dice in any pool are red Trouble dice. You can use Faith to “push” a failed roll, re-rolling dice; but any 1s you roll on the re-rolled Trouble dice cause extra problems. It simulates “digging deep” into the things that drive you, and the undoing that overreaching can cause you. Faith points refill by acting in line with your character beliefs, but their limited nature refutes the rate of re-rolling seen in games like Mutant: Year Zero and makes pushing seem like a dramatic, narrative-laden event.

Sometimes big A4 hardback games feel like there’s a huge reading requirement, but although there’s a lot of material included in Tales of the Old West, much of it is optional. After the first five chapters, you can pretty much skip to the starting adventure, and just pick it up as you go along. That adventure itself is simple, flavoursome and fun; the writers have given lots of thought to chunks of text to read out to bring NPCs to life. My only real criticism is the terrible quasi-Texan accent I was drawling out for most of the evening.

When you do dig deeper, there’s everything here from frontier town development, lassooing rules and how to conduct social conflict via sternly worded letter. Two highlights for me were the gambling rules that let you simulate an evening of tense poker in about three dice rolls, and the tidy quickdraw Duel mechanics for those climatic sunset showdowns.

The savvy mix of light-weight core rules with these thematic modular add-ons means that Tales of the Old West handily manages to be the best Wild West RPG I’ve encountered—and it’s also my favourite implementation of the Year Zero engine so far. So, if you’ve got a hankerin’ for a hoedown, and think you can swing a sixgun with the best of them? It’s time to saddle on up and give it a play!

 

PLAY IT? MUST PLAY

If you want to play roleplay games in the Wild West, Tales of the Old West is ready to strap on some stirrups and take you on an adventure. Beginner friendly, but begging for you to dive into years of world-building too; we give it a solid Tabletop Gaming recommendation.

TRY THIS IF YOU liked Frontier Scum…

…Frontier Scum is sillier, leaner, nastier and more lethal than Tales of the Old West. If you want to be gunslingin’ outlaws, that may be all you need, but Tales lets you live in an expansive world and perhaps express a smidge more nuance into your cowboy games.

About Tales of the Old West
DesignerDave Semark and Matthew Tyler-Jones
PublisherEffekt Publishing
Playcount2-5 Players
AgeAge 12+
Price£50
Contents
  • A4 Hardback 300 pages
RatingMust Play

A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2025.