If, like me, your first ever miniature game involved rows and rows of tiny geckos, you may have been sad when Warhammer Fantasy Battles was discontinued back in 2014. Over the last decade, much of that community fantasy energy has found a new home in Kings of War; and this 4th Edition Starter Set dives in with a brand new faction; a Mongol-empire themed canine race called the Xirkaali.
It’s always a challenge reviewing a new edition of a game; are you covering it for KoW old hats? For current miniature gamers looking for a new system? Or for players completely new to massed plastic warfare? Approaching this box-set from the beginners perspective, assembling the new models were fairly straightforward and enjoyable, although some clearer guidance definitely wouldn’t have hurt. There are multiple models for each unit type, but only one guidance photo in the online guidance; the bare minimum really. Two of us assembled everything in around six hours, and it was less fiddly than some of the modern fantasy plastics from games like Age of Sigmar. We particularly loved the new Trident Realm miniatures; whilst the new Xirkaali dogs troops are competently modelled, they’re a little too ‘serious’ for my taste (although I’ll admit that’s like complaining that Necrons don’t smile enough). Unlike traditional rank-and-flank games, Kings of War doesn’t use individual models on individual bases grouped in trays, but instead groups models on one larger base. This speeds up gameplay, and also allows you to make big dynamic dioramas on each base. There are plus sides and downsides to both, but be warned that painting ten models glued on one base is much more challenging than painting them separately!
In terms of gameplay, and unlike most modern warfare miniaturing, the Kings of War ruleset is heavily built around manoeuvring. If you’ve ever read Bernard Cornwell’s Sharpe series, you’ll be aware of the power and devastating risk of poorly planned formations, and getting your units flanked is equally perilous here. A unit gets double attacks from the side, and triple from the rear! (That’s 50+ dice in some cases!). The starter rulebook devotes plenty of space to diagrams and explanations of these movements, and we never once found an edge case that wasn’t covered or confused us. In fact, unlike our experience with the otherwise superb Armoured Clash Starter Set, the cut-down rule book is excellent; it’s got very nearly everything the full rulebook does, with definitions, stats and absolutely everything needed for playing with the included models. The only real error we found anywhere was the army profile sheets confusingly used the old term “Heavy Infantry” instead the newer “Large Infantry”. There are also no counters, dice or measuring sticks, which I’d normally hope to see. Experienced players will have these, but absolute beginners may not.
Kings of War is absolutely superb to play. To be honest, I approached it expecting something just a little tedious and traditional—”It still uses full turns rather than alternating actions? Urgh…”—and had my expectations absolutely turned upside down. Every design decision has been made to incorporate meaningful decisions and strategic play. That full army activation? It makes positioning mistakes absolutely devastating, and allows opponents to take advantage of them with devastating effects. My favourite mechanic here is that units don’t have hit points or wounds, they build up damage which increases the risk that they rout and are destroyed, but never with any guarantee. Routing is thus possible to estimate but ultimately unpredictable, and causes fascinating strategy twists and turns.
For those with experience of the previous 3rd Edition, the rules have been re-worked to cover the core foundations first, with unit specific rules changes incorporated only as you need them. Nerve has also been reduced to a single stat, and in fitting with a game built on melee combat, has been used to slightly nerf ranged attacks; archers and the like can now only destroy or “rout” troops that have already been absolutely “devastated”, whilst close combat can potentially destroy even only slightly damaged units. Comparing old and new rules is a great way to see the rewrite has led to clearer initial reads; it took me a couple of takes to understand the 3rd Edition Nerve rules, whilst I understood 4th straight away.
PLAY IT? MUST-PLAY
I can’t think of a fantasy miniatures game that comes close for me. The ability to wear down units but never really know if they’ll collapse? The vital impact of positioning? The horrible sea-dwelling monsters? Kings of War has everything, and you’ll love playing it.
TRY THIS IF YOU liked War Cry…
…The more obvious comparison would be Warhammer Old World, since Warcry is at the skirmish end of the fantasty spectrum. However the level of streamlining in Kings of War allows for tactical play without some of the crunchy delay that we’ve grown to expect from some of Warcry’s big siblings.
| About Kings of War: Claws in the Sand – Two Player Starter Set | |
|---|---|
| Designer | Alessio Cavatore |
| Publisher | Mantic Games |
| Playcount | 2 players |
| Age | 14+ |
| Price | £100 |
| Contents | - 16x HIPS Hard Plastic Xirkaali Warriors/Spearwardens Miniatures - 10x HIPS Hard Plastic Yan infantry Miniatures - 1x MasterCraft resin Xirkaali Matriarch Miniature - 6x HIPS Hard Plastic Depth Horror Miniatures - 16x HIPS Hard Plastic Placoderm Miniatures - 10x HIPS Hard Plastic Riverguard Miniatures - 1x PVC Plastic Depth Horror Eternal - 1x Slimline Rulebook (includes an Introduction to Pannithor, Core Rules & Army Building) - 1x Getting Started Sheet - 2x Army Profile Sheets (including assembly guide) - Bases |
| Rating | Must Play |
A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2025.

