There’s something very satisfying about protecting a castle from monsters. Castle Panic traps players inside an irresponsibly vulnerable citadel whilst a variety of horrible creatures approach. To survive, they must work, co-operatively, to defeat the onslaught. First released in 2009, the designer likely took inspiration from the digital ‘Tower Defence’ genre that exploded around that time. Fans of those addictive mobile games, with their unending waves of unstoppable horrors, will probably enjoy Castle Panic.
I’ve been a fan of this game for years. It’s well balanced – our first game this week came down to one monster, one remaining tower, and one card – with easy-to-learn mechanics. It’s also significantly less stressful than standout co-op rival Pandemic, and a points based score for each player can reduce the ‘quarterback’ effect that some co-operative games suffer from, where an experienced player orders everyone else around. This second edition features new artwork and a brand new expansion. We’ve taken a look here at the Big Box version, one cavernous case containing the base game and all 4 expansions; The Dark Titan, The Wizard’s Tower, Engines of War and the new Crowns and Quests.
A full explanation of everything in this mighty chest is beyond the scope of this review, but in brief, the expansions take the simpler puzzle of the base game, and expand upon it in a variety of interesting ways.
The most obvious addition is more types, strengths and flavours of monsters. Extras like flame breathing mechanics and flying beasts increase the challenge facing your plucky rampart dwellers. Every expansion adds these, alongside new ways to counteract them.
The Dark Titan adds Agranok, a powerful new super-enemy, with support tokens and a mounted Cavelier to aid players. The Wizard’s Tower brings an extra tower for the game, and a powerful Wizard’s deck. The added decision space here is well thought-out; powerful as many of the more swingy Wizard cards are, they rely on the normal Castle cards for synergy, leading to interesting choices about which type to pick up or discard.
Complexity comes along with Engines of War’s light economic dressing, which adds resources and the ability to build Catapults and Equipment with an Engineer. It certainly widens the options for strategy and planning, although I’m not sure the added complication and play-time actually provides any more fun than the vanilla version. However, for those who find the base game too simple, this adds a crunchier depth.
Finally, the newest addition, Crowns and Quests, brings a campaign aspect to the game, with differently skilled characters and multiple objective-filled quests to complete on the route to victory. Of the four, this expansion adds the greatest variety and replayability, all without messing with the core experience of the game too much. I’d suggest this and Wizard’s Tower as the stand outs, although all of them add something interesting and unique. The designers recommend only really using one at a time; throwing in all four would be complex, chaotic, and… I kinda want to try it.
Now, I don’t think Fireside Games have done a particularly good job at a box insert. Whilst tokens and cards have a little symbol on them to differentiate between each expansion, setup is still too lengthy for my taste, and I’m confident a better moulded insert with clearly labelled sections for each expansion could have hugely reduced this. Due to this, the light-weight Castle Panic takes nearly half its play time again to set up. A few plastic bags eased things, but I’d hoped not to have to take on the organisation myself.
Alongside this, the rule book doesn’t take quite enough time to hold your hand through the increased pieces and complexity of the Big Box experience. Searching through the multiple expansions’ rules during play would have been much easier with an index too – although I’m sure this is not the last time I’ll be ranting about that problem.
Those gripes aside; like Carcassonne’s Big Box there’s enough additional gameplay here to keep a group going for years, and compared to purchasing it all separately, it’s a decent price. If you enjoyed the first edition, or if you fancy a new experience that’s great for dedicated gaming groups and families alike, you should definitely put up some cardboard walls, wind up your catapult, and give Castle Panic a try.
PLAY IT? MUST PLAY
An adventure for your gang that’s fun every time, with enough options to steadily take you from gateway gauziness to gamer’s game.
TRY THIS IF YOU liked 5 Minute Dungeon…
…Castle Panic takes the theme, the co-operative challenge and fairly short play time, but ditches the chaos and brain trauma of 5 Minute Dungeon’s real time element.
| About Castle Panic Big Box Edition | |
|---|---|
| Designer | James Kniffen |
| Publisher | Fireside Games |
| Playcount | 1-6 Players |
| Age | Age 10+ |
| Price | £120 |
| Contents |
|
| Rating | Must Play |
A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2021.