Scales of Fate review

I cast thee into the Abyss—or do I cast myself?

Veiled Fate was a bit of a smash hit when it came out, a blend of social deduction and strategy, something like the love child of Blood on the Clocktower and Blood Rage. In the same universe comes Scales of Fate, using a familiar pantheon but replacing the multiplayer approach with a strictly two player duel

Players are assigned two secret demigod cards at the beginning of the game, and participate in a head-to-head battle of deduction, attempting to do two things; work out the identity of their opponent’s demigods and to position their own demigods in ways that score them points without giving away their identity.

As with most IV Studio games, the level of production here is fantastic, although I’m not sure if the chunky wooden deluxe pieces are really necessary for a game with quite simple mechanics. I actually think the core ideas could be compressed into a £25 small box edition quite comfortably, without sacrificing much of the experience.

The board consists of an abstract grid of unusual shapes, with a numbered points track round the outside, and an Abyss—the Hell analogue for this setting—to cast unlucky demigods into. Demigods will be moved up and down the track based on actions taken on the grid, and a player’s score is based either on the distance between their two demigod tokens—so if one is on 3, and another on 8, the player’s score is 5—or if both demigods are on the same space they score the value written on the space.

Points are also available for guessing your opponent’s demigods: three if you get them both, zero if you guess one, and lose a point if you can’t work out either of their identities.

The game is split into three Ages, in which a set of nine quest tokens are placed on the grid with action tiles between some of them. The layout of these is set on the current Age Card, with one red “special guest” token. Players take it in turns to place demigod tokens on action tiles, which either grant servant tokens, Smite a demigod into the Abyss, or let you adjust the fate of those in the Abyss.

The servant tokens activate particular quests; all quest tiles have a number and a symbol on them, and when activated they grant or take that many points from adjacent demigods. Where you place each demigod is thus important, not just for the action token you get to use, but also for future activation of quests adjacent to that demigod. So, when I pick up the yellow Naka demigod, and place it next to the +3 quest, am I manoeuvring to increase her score?! Or perhaps I think you are Naka, and I’m attempting to reduce the gap between your demigods?! Or is it a bluff? Or is my bluff, the actual bluff, in some Machievallian double bluff?!

At the end of each Age, the Age card poses a question such as “Are any of your demigods at a score between 8 and 10?”. Both players answer this, revealing a further piece of tantalising truth that may narrow down on their hidden identities.

There is just enough information available in Scales of Fate to make guessing very easy to attempt, but very difficult to be certain about. In most of the games we’ve played one player has managed to guess both of the opponents colours, and victory always feels like winning a bizarre game of poker where you only had about half the cards.

If I could nitpick about one thing: I didn’t feel that the special quests or the later Age cards add the additional tension they could have done. In related IV game Pillars of Fate, the later Ages significantly increase numbers at stake with options like “gain ten” points, whereas the most powerful in Scales is “gain three”. That’s a minor point though, the central challenge of guessing out your opponent whilst obsfuscating your own behaviour makes Scales of Fate an enjoyable puzzle every time.

PLAY IT? MUST-PLAY

If you enjoy out-smarting and out-thinking your opponent, Scales of Fate provides a novel new playing field that’s a visual, tactile and strategic delight.

TRY THIS IF YOU liked Citadels…

…A veteran game these days, Citadels involves a constantly shifting identity amidst a central tableau building mechanic. It’s more straightforward in concept than Scales of Fate, but both are filled with hoodwinking.

About Scales of Fate
DesignerMax Anderson, Zac Dixon, Austin Harrison
PublisherIV Studio
Playcount2 players
Age12+
Price£40 standard/£55 deluxe
Contents- Game board - 18 Demigod cards - 9 Age cards - 2 Guide cards - 2 Score pads - 2 Pencils - 7 Action tiles - 12 Quest tokens - Abyss marker - 9 Renown markers - 3 God power tokens - 9 Demigod markers - 4 Servant tokens - First player marker - Rulebook
RatingMust Play
A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2026.