There’s two types of classic games out there; there’s the modern classics – widely known games such as Carcassonne and Settlers of Catan that have become cultural touchstones for the hobby. But there’s also the other classics; the titles that outsell our favourites by thousands. I’m reluctantly referring to Monopoly, of course, but also Cluedo, Pictionary and too many more. Of these, Risk is one of the least painful for me to accept on a bookshelf; it’s actually a real game, with interesting choices and a tactical simplicity that allows players to focus on empire building and permanently ruining their real life friendships in equal measure. In fact, I enjoy Risk so much I’ve even made my own map for our town, incorporating Warrington’s estates and elegant motorway network.
I was therefore interested – and apprehensive – when I heard of a short card game version of Risk. Risk Strike aims to condense the core of the multi-hour world-conquering experience down into 20 minutes. An ambitious task, and one that it sort of achieves, mechanically anyway.
Firstly, this is rather a pretty little box. A small punchy design with gold foil, and only a little wasted space on the inlay. The included cards are precisely illustrated, and the continent tokens are substantial. The dice are actually chunkier than those I received with my copy of the full Risk!
The core loop of play is easily learnt. On your turn, you pick up two cards; any combination from the continent and tactics decks. The former gives locations for you to place in front up you, the latter provides the tools you need to steal those locations.
You then choose to attack, or not. If you hold of your invading forces, you gain a bonus tactics card. Otherwise, you place one or more “Troop” tactics cards by one of your continents and attack an opponent’s continent card. The defender can also place troops in response.
Attacker and defender then roll a dice for each troop card they have played, exactly as in Risk. Dice are paired in order of result, and the loser of each pair loses a troop card. If the attacker runs out of troops the attack is over; if the defence runs out then the attacker steals their Continent card.
When any player reaches a full assortment of Continent cards – 3 for Australia, 5 for Europe, 8 for Asia – they gain a Continent coin. The winner of the game is the first person to two coins.
It’s easy to pick up… and much, much too reliant on luck. It’s almost always better to take two Continent cards than two Tactics ones, just in the hope that you complete the two 3 card Continents before anyone else does. Attacking is much less efficient, costing your whole turn, and with cards such as “Sabotage” easily cancelling out your whole attack; the best strategy is a blind drawing of Continent cards. Adding to the overpowered defence, some of the defensive Tactics cards are ambiguously worded, potentially making them even stronger.
The game ends so easily without strategy that it took us three plays to even realise there’s an end game state; when all the continent cards have been handed out and all that is left is fighting. In other words most Risk Strike sessions emulate just the setup stage of original Risk, many games ending before actually getting to the bit that is, you know, a game. We found that Strike is much better when you delay this end by ruling that a player needs three (or, in two player games, four) continent coins to win.
Even if one were to look past the multiple gameplay quibbles, Risk Strike doesn’t really retain the soul of the original. The most satisfying moments in Risk come when hurling a stack of troops against an opponent and sweeping through a continent. Here, the most you can ever take is a single card, and it’s arguably not even worth attempting to do that.
PLAY IT? MAYBE
We don’t always want to spend most of a day taking over the world. For a light, family-friendly game, Risk Strike has something to offer – although I’d probably want to change a few rules. Or just play Risk with a time limit.
TRY THIS IF YOU liked Monopoly Deal…
…If you thought Monopoly Deal was fantastic, Risk Strike will be a nice way to pass a dull afternoon. If you thought Deal was purely luck-based and fundamentally flawed? You’ll enjoy Strike even less!
| About RISK Strike | |
|---|---|
| Designer | George Feledichuk, David Rudow & Leo Taylor |
| Publisher | Avalon Hill |
| Playcount | 2-5 Players |
| Age | Age 10+ |
| Price | £20 |
| Contents |
|
| Rating | Maybe |
A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2022.
