Rallyman: DIRT review

Dare the dirt, but don’t drop your dice.

There are two things – in cardboard format – that I’m always a sucker for: driving games and fictional sports. Weirdly, I actually have a moderate disregard for both in real life. I enjoy running, maybe a little basketball, but I’ve no idea who won the Champions League last year, and I don’t care. Yet make up a nonsense sport, with a board and dice and ball throwing and fouls? Blood Bowl, Dreadball, Blitz Bowl… I’m always there.

Driving is the same for me. Jumping in the car is a chore, and long drives are my nightmare fuel. But racing games? Whether it’s Car Wars, Gaslands or even the hand management cycling-supremacy of Flamme Rouge – I’m always up for the challenge.

Part of the joy in these things for me are the very reasons they suck in real life. Crashing into another car is Gaslands is hilarious. Doing it is reality is dangerous, and – worse – expensive! As a long time fan of Holy Grail Games, their take on the genre was exciting to me, and I think they’ve managed something unique.

Specifically, Rallyman: DIRT is set in the sport of “rally” racing, where cars aren’t trying to beat each other simulatenous, but in a staggered time trial, trying to set the best speed for the course. This is a novel take on the concept; I’ve never played a racing game that didn’t try to start you all at approximately the same start position, with the aim of being first over the finish line. Here, it’s your efficiency of speed is all that matters; in one game with my son, he overtook me and beat me to the finish line but actually still lost once the cards were added up. Which is… fine? I guess? It’s just, you know, he overtook me and beat me over the finishing line, but was still apparently slower than me… somehow?

The game uses a system of different dice; for gears, coasting and braking. You place down the dice in a series of spaces on the track in front of your car. You can put down a gear dice of the same number, higher or lower; a coasting dice to do the same speed; or braking, plus a gear dice, to drop a gear. So, if you start the turn in gear three; you could put down “three”, “coast”, “coast”, “four”, “five” and then “six”; to end the turn in sixth gear. The gear you finish in dictates which time card you take at the end, awarding you from 50 seconds to 15, depending on that finishing speed. Thus, it’s ideal to end in a high gear; except it’s rarely wise to go that fast on these twisty-turny tracks.

Once you’ve placed your dice you roll them, either one at a time – allowing you to stop early if things are looking dangerous – or all at once, carving off a bonus second per die off your time. All well and good, but if you roll three alert icons, you lose control and spin hazardously off the road. This gains you a Gear 0 card, and depending on the difficulty of the track tile you are on, causes you damage that can limit your dice options. Some tile spaces have a top speed, such as on sharp corners, making each player drop their speed so they can wheel round the corner, or drop into a slide at a slightly higher speed but on a longer route.

The generous amount of tiles in Rallyman: DIRT gives you the possibility of building a sprawling tableful of spaghetti-like dirt track; it’s just a shame that there’s not as much variability as there could be. Expansion packs offer hill climbs, closed circuit racing and different car types, but none of that is in the core box. We found ourselves familiar with the admittedly gorgeous tiles very quickly, and a box this big should have included a lot more variability.

In the same way, although the core mechanic of placing dice and picking a line is a welcome bite-sized brain-puzzle each turn, it’s not drop-your-jaw captivating. The damage tokens are too variable, which can hurt players a little too randomly for my taste. In one game I lost both my coast dice very early, whilst my opponent made the exact same error I did but only drew green flags – receiving no damage. For the rest of the race I was hobbled in my strategy, whilst they clung to a fairly conservative approach and still pulled effortlessly ahead.

Rallyman: DIRT describes itself as “an addictively simply rally game with a lot of strategic depth”. I think it oversells both the addiction and the level of strategy. There’s certainly a decent game here, but I’m not sure there’s enough to justify the cost.

 

PLAY IT? YES

It’s fun, quick to teach and very pretty. Rallyman: DIRT is great to play as a light bit of entertainment with some friends, but look elsewhere for deep strategy.

TRY THIS IF YOU liked Heat: Pedal to the Metal…

…Both offer simple and thematic mechanics, and Heat is the better game, but there’s something to be said that a game of Rallyman: DIRT can be played in 15 minutes.

About Rallyman: DIRT
DesignerJean-Christophe Bouvier
PublisherHoly Grail Games
Playcount1-6 Players
AgeAge 14+
Price£60
Contents
  • 1 Rulebook
  • 6 Cars6 Dashboards
  • 6 Driver cards
  • 6 Gaming Aids
  • 6 SISU tokens
  • 122 second tokens
  • 6 Tire cards
  • 48 Damage tokens
  • 11 Dice
  • 174 Time cards
  • 1 Assistance tile
  • 1 Damage Token Back
  • 31 Double-sided track tiles
RatingYes

 

A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2022.