It’s often said that puns are the lowest form of humour. If so, it’s a fair prediction that games relying on puns for their humour would be the lowest form of games. Puns of Anarchy does its best to prove that theory correct. It is a party game for 3 or more players, with a disturbingly long play time of 30 to 90 minutes?! Anyone who submits themselves to an hour and a half of this part-planned word play probably deserves their fate.
The core mechanic gives players three wipe-clean cards, with well-known phrases on them, like ‘Saving Private Ryan’. Armed with a pen, players must attempt to alter the cards into puns that fit a category. Thus ‘Shaving Ryan’s Privates’ might fit a ‘Bathroom’ category, whilst ‘Braving Irate Lion’ could work for ‘In The Zoo’. Players compete to write the funniest puns for each category. Laughter, apparently, ensues.
The flaw here is simple, obvious and two-fold. Firstly, writing good puns is hard. Add in having to fit the puns into specific categories, and it becomes impossible to do with reliable success. Much of our games involved staring blankly at cards, eventually giving up and writing something that sort of fitted the category, but absolutely wasn’t amusing.
Secondly, even fantastic, amazing, close-to-perfect puns are only ever about a 5/10 funny. A groan-with-a-reluctant-respect kind of funny. The sort of funny that works, occasionally, sprinkled into conversation between friends. A flimsy, light-weight humour that simply can’t hold up under sustained assault. And remember, that’s good puns. We were writing bad puns. Non-joke puns. Just words, that sort of fit. Ish. We read through the finished cards, and struggled to choose a winner for any category due to the absolute mediocrity of every entry.
I’m afraid Puns of Anarchy is not a good game. There might, just about, be room for it in your house if you are a family of pun-makers – although it unfortunately makes the unwise decision to exclude children with mature themes on some cards. But yes, a group of die-hard, dedicated, adult-only pun-makers might have a few chuckles one evening, crafting masterful plays-on-words within the limitations the game provides you. For the rest of us? Avoid it. You’ll only be pun-ishing yourself. Get it? Of course you do.
PLAY IT? NO
| About Puns of Anarchy | |
|---|---|
| Designer | Evan Katz & Josh Roberts |
| Publisher | Charty Party |
| Playcount | 3+ Players |
| Age | Age 17+ |
| Price | £25 |
| Contents |
|
| Rating | No |
A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2021.
