Knock Issue 4 review

A grab-bag of Old School chitterlings, challenges and celebration

Knock is an esoteric old-school roleplay smorgasbord. This edition is the 4th version from the talented team at The Merry Mushmen; a magazine rammed with articles, adventures and avant-garde Miscellanea.

Even from the outside you can tell the book’s going to be chock-full of weirdness; the cover has a d8 table of alternatives to a TPK (Total Party Kill)—the two strongest looking PCs must fight to the death to amuse a Priestess—and there’s a d6 table interesting idols squeezed onto the spine of the book. It’s these kind of ideas that make Knock special; the mechanical subversion of tropey legends like “TPK”, and the crazy idea to fit content in places no normal release ever considers.

Each issue even comes with a GM screen adventure wrapped around each issue; although if I’m being honest, I wish this was made of decently thick card rather than easily-dented paper. Issue 4 is hugged Eric Nieudan’s The Lost City Sandox: a double spread sandbox adventure in a city of evil drug-peddling cultists with a population pumped full of pharmaceuticals. Drugs are an amusing addition to RPGs— I don’t even drink alcohol, but I’ll jump at the chance to roleplay the effects of wyrd chemicals on the human system. The d66 table of the results of the “cyrulean haze” are perfected crafted to create hilarious scenes at the table; entries like “PCs believe their touch is poisonous” or “Behaves like a tour guide, following people and explaining random facts in a loud manner”. With the addition of a Master Table of escalating events, operating much like MORK BORG’s miseries, Lost City is the full package.

And that’s just the outside of Knock 4; arguably worth the price of admission without even cracking it open! The challenge for reviewing a project so frenetically eclectic is that it’s impossible to succinctly convey what’s inside. Certainly there’s no consistent theme, no overarching thread to follow; if you’re looking for that, then Knock will leave you sorely disappointed. Unless… the consistency you actually crave is a deep dedication to this silly hobby of playing pretend; if you wish to follow in the footsteps of others who imitate reality where it’s helpful, and toss it out the window in freewheeling disarray when it’s not. Knock demands (and rewards) commitment; one article “Playing D&D in the Wargaming Way: A Manifesto” requires the reader to reframe their thoughts so that GM and players are not simply opponents, they are “learning to dance together”.

This book also looks gorgeous… as long as you enjoy thoughtfully erratic typography and cramming words where they possibly shouldn’t go. Oliver Revenu’s layout takes a ‘whitespace is something that happens to other people’ sort of approach, and I’m sure some of my ADHD friends will find this a nightmare to navigate. I found it beautiful and engaging, so your mileage may vary.

All the contents are built for OSR games like Old School Essentials. There’s at least five full adventure modules, several bestiaries (Skerple’s d40 Discount Monsters is pretty fun), alongside fistfuls of variant magic ideas, alternative armour systems and DRAGONS!

My personal favourite is a fascinating article by Josh McCrowell called The Hobbit as a Setting. It’s a thought experiment on “What if Lord of the Rings had never existed?”. What if the cornerstone canon of fantasy gaming had been just JRR Tolkien’s original 1937 edition of The Hobbit? As a result, Middle earth becomes “The Wilderland”, and the triune foundations of RPG are “Treasure Hunting, Journeys and Singing”; with rules to back it up! It’s a cheerful, considered and practical rethink of a world most of us might never have really appraised. That’s Knock in a nutshell. It may not for everyone, but if Gandalf being demoted to “Just a wizard” appeals to you? The rest of Knock is going to blow your mind!

 

PLAY IT? MUST PLAY

Knock is something that will live on gamers shelves as an wildly amusing diversion and an indispensable reference volume for years to come. Although… if that sounds like it’s not “your sort of thing”, it’s probably not.

TRY THIS IF YOU liked Pirate Borg…

…Both are ornate and old-school, although there’s slightly more pirates in one than the other. There’s even some cross-over, since Pirate Borg’s Luke Stratton has contributed a delicious dice-drop island map generator to Knock!

About Knock Issue 4
DesignerEric Nieudan and Oliver Revenu
PublisherThe Merry Mushmen
AgeAge 14+
Price£32
Contents
  • Softcover, A5, 216 pages
RatingMust Play

A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2023.