Kingyo review

Go for gold(fish)

Kingyo-Sukui (known as “goldfish scooping” or “????”) is a traditional game played at Japanese summer festivals. Contestants scoop goldfish from a pool, using a special paper scooper known as a “poi”, attempting to pick up as many fish as possible until the poi tears and breaks. In some versions faster fish called “medaka” are added, increasing the challenge of catching them. Simple, but popular, Kingyo-Sukui has been played for over 200 years, and – thanks to Jyde games- it is now available in board game form as Kingyo.

Now, I’m an absolute sucker for Japanese game design, which is so often tight, tiny and cute. Games like Onitamo, Metro X and Songbirds fit much more in a small package than you might otherwise expect, so the very existence of the culture-inspired Kingyo was exciting.

Setup is fast; spread the seventy-five kingyo (fish) cards over the table, with five randomly flipped face-down. Now spread some medaku cards around too, one less than the number of players.

Mixed in are also three additional card types, featuring a dragonfly, a hornet and a scoop (poi) on them. These have special actions; picking up a dragonfly lets you re-roll the dice, changing the fish choices available for the table to pick-up. A hornet means opponents must discard a face down card from their bowl, whilst the scoop let’s you pick up one of the face down cards.

The goal of the game is to pull as many fish off the table as you can. A neat little foam dice tray contains the 5 custom dice, with sides in a variety of colours that match the kingyo (fish) cards.

One player rolls the dice, and then everyone starts fishing, simultaneously. You can only pull cards that match the dice – so a kingyo card with two blue fish and one red needs you to have at least three dice of those colours.

Players call out the name of the fish they’ve picked up, yelling “blue”, or “dragonfly” as they hurl cards into their bowl. The aim is for a mad flurry of people shouting and grabbing cards; an effect akin to dinnertime with the Lost Boys in Hook. Unfortunately? It’s nowhere near as fun as that.

Each dice roll does cause a brief flurry, but then the action is over due to an inevitable lack of cards to pick up. The action cards aren’t particularly inspiring – the hornet’s “throw a card back in” is rarely impactful, and the scoop allows you to select a facedown card. Picking up a card that’s exactly the same as all the face-up kingyo cards? Underwhelming. At some point, when you feel you (or your team) can’t pick up any more cards, grabbing a medaka card will end your game. If they had significantly higher value, or reduced in points the later they were picked up a la Camel Up leg betting, they might be more exciting; sadly they are all worth four points, nearly the same as a three point kingyo card.

There are rules for team play, including a one-versus-many mode, but they don’t elevate Kingyo beyond mediocre. Calling out the actions doesn’t magically make them more interesting, and potentially even removes any hope of deception or strategy from the game.

The optional character mode creates asymmetry, with players choosing between a passive effect such as “each purple kingyo in your bowl at the end of the game is worth an extra point”, or an action like “When an an opponent picks up a dragonfly, each of your team members can pick up a face-down kingyo card”. This adds a slight variability, but doesn’t save Kingyo from being dull. And, unforgiveably, in a box around three times than it needs to be! Ultimately, even my six year old quickly tired of the action, asking if we could play Hive instead. If I were you, I would do the same.

 

PLAY IT? NO

This is barely a game, and you shouldn’t waste your time on it. Apparently, they also play kyarakut?-sukui in Japan, a game about bobbing for tiny action figures. Try emptying some Unmatched into the bath and give it a try instead of bothering with Kingyo.

TRY THIS IF YOU liked Hey That’s My Fish…

…This ice floe disappearing, friend blocking, fish stockpiling classic is a perfect five-minute family game. Kingyo is much worse, but it does at least also involve seafood.

About Kingyo
DesignerAlexis Allard & Émilien Alquier
PublisherJyde games
Playcount2-6 Players
AgeAge 7+
Price£23
Contents
  • Dice track
  • 5 Custom dice
  • 75 Kingyo cards
  • 5 Medaka cards
  • 6 Bowl cards
  • 6 character cards
RatingNo

A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2022.