Distilled review

Crack open a cardboard cask

Distilled

Look, whisky is horrible. We all know it. Even the people who pretend to like it are just trying to win cool points from the bloke with the huge beard in the corner. And yet, the art of fermenting sugars, carefully aging them in a barrel and serving them out in tasteful yet tempting bottles? I’ll admit I see the attraction, even if the stuff itself is barely swallowable.

In Distilled, you compete with your friends to make whiskies, gins, vodkas, and a number of other high-end spirits. The aim is to earn the most spirit points by the end of the game.

The brain cruncher here, as with any good euro, is that you start with nowhere near enough resources to do what you want. As the seven years of the game progress, you slowly become richer, and build the engine of your distillery. Finally you have enough that you could start to finally enact all those plans you have… except at that point, the game ends. If that sounds frustrating, I don’t mean it like that – well, maybe a little – Distilled is an enjoyably tight puzzle, one that rewards planning and pushing your luck without being too punishing.

The core to that timing challenge is the concept of aged spirits. No one wants a one year old scotch or a brand new brandy; it’s through leaving barrels to mature through multiple years that they gain flavour and value. This calls for constant compromise between making cheap, nasty moonshine that you can sell immediately, or attempting to perfect an oak barrel of vintage rum, but not earning any income from it for multiple turns. The obvious solution would be to wait until you have more resources at game end – but then you run out of years to actually age the spirit. It’s a interesting decision, with no obviously right or wrong answers.

The Distill phase adds to this with a push-your-luck mechanic that manages to be beautifully thematic; real life distilleries remove the start and end liquid from stills, the “heads” and the “tails”. One tastes bad, the other is too alcoholic. These aren’t thrown away though – they are reused in future distillations. In Distilled, every time you make a spirit, you shuffle then remove the top and bottom cards from your washback. This is problematic, because brewing a specific spirit recipe involves having the correct ingredients in place. If you include two grain sugars, but one is removed, that expensive whisky you were trying to make has become a cheap vodka.

This leads to a tantalising decision – do you stuff your washback full of expensive ingredients, so that if two important components are removed you still make what you planned? Or do you run the risk of adding the bare minimum, maximising profits – or decimating them if you bet fails you.

Couple the distillation process with the aging mechanic and no choice is ever quite quite certain in Distilled. There’s no predictable path to success; I’ve had people win by repeatedly putting moonshine in beautiful bottles (that increase the value, and gain set collection points), and I’ve seen someone languish in poverty all game, only to real two ancient brews in the final turns and rake in a small fortune.

The box also includes various “tasting flights”; groups of recipes and countries, allowing variety, but also disrupting the balance between aged spirits and non-aged spirits. A fully aged game involves more patience, taking risks with early attempts in the stills, whilst non-aged is a faster game of shiny bottles and fancy ingredients.

The entire game is a love letter to the art of making fine spirits, and one can appreciate the care and attention to detail even if you think people seem to obsessing over drinks that taste and smell like bleach. The art is beautiful and absolutely evokes the feeling on sitting on an uncomfortable stool in the back room of a pub on a remote Scottish island. It doesn’t hurt that the game itself goes down very smoothly too. Aaah, that’s peaty…

 

PLAY IT? MUST PLAY

A medium-weight eurogame wrapped in polished mahogany and cut crystal. An innovative and interesting experience that brings a much loved theme to life

TRY THIS IF YOU liked Caverna…

…both are fairly complicated games with a constant awareness of time passing quickly, but – unlike Agricola – both provide players relative freedom in how they use their actions.

About Distilled
DesignerDave Beck
PublisherPaverson Games
Playcount1-5 Players
AgeAge 14+
Price£35
Contents
  • 333 cards
  • 187 cardboard tokens
  • 68 mini cards
  • 43 wooden tokens
  • 20 large tasting flight cards
  • 5 player boards
  • 5 dual-layered recipe boards
  • 5 large player reference cards
  • 3 main game boards
  • 2 rulebooks
  • 3 removable source trays with lids and box organizer
RatingMust Play

 

A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2021.