Death Game review

Only one will survive, and it probably won’t be you.

There’s been a glut of popular media about fight-to-the-death style scenarios in recent years. Video like Battle Royale, Hunger Games, Squid Game; stories of normal people being thrust into life-or-death situations where they have to kill, or be killed themselves. Death Game by Laurie O’Connel is an excellent attempt to replicate that massed encounter in a way that still works without having to kidnap fifty of your mates and lock them in an abandoned crossbow-crammed maze.

Death Game runs on a purpose-built system that has built constructed specifically for the premise. It begins with players collaboratively decide on a setting; are they in a high-school, a billionaire’s mansion, the North Pole? They secretly vote on a gimmick; everything is flooding, the giraffes are robots, gravity turns off sometimes… Then they quickly create characters, and jump into a game, with one player as the GM.

Running these sorts of RPGs can be quite stressful; managing a cast of 50 NPCs and a mysterious evil masterplan sounds like a nightmare, right? Death Game side-steps this with a rolling GM; when your character dies you take on the GM role. So players get a lovely gruesome moment in the spotlight, then get to sit back and narrate everyone else’s destruction.

The book is presented in a clear, stark monotone, peppered with pictures from Hodag RPG, one of my favourite illustrators in the scene. Much like their work in the excellent horror-brawleer Dead Beats, Hodag’s art is grubbly and hand-drawn and perfect in tone for Death Game. The book **even comes with a bonus full colour future-castle setting pamphlet.

The main action check in the game is against Peril; anything you do, if failed, increases your Peril by 1 and triggers a Death Save; roll a d12 and roll over your Peril—or die. Similar to Mothership’s Panic System, but triggered nearly every action, it’s a comedically fast death spiral, and absolutely the appropriate mechanic for killing off tens of characters in a session. Characters can also make promises to one another for boosts to rolls if they are fulfilled; I would have quite liked some mechanic for breaking these agreements too, although it’s easy enough to home-rule.

Now, there are a few structural oddities to the book. Character creation comes before an explanation that each game will start with creating the wider setting; being asked to write PC’s motivations without any explanation of what the setting will be jarred the first time I read through—and why do so many RPG authors refuse including indexes?! Still, these are minor quibbles. More than half the book is dedicated to appendices, with a multi-page example of play, and multiple standalone settings. The example of play is a demonstrative point-perfect specimen; I started reading it with a rough idea of how Death Game is played, by the end I completely understood the process, the pacing, the tone; everything. Every RPG book needs an example this good.

As a point of comparison, I reviewed Evil Hat’s similarly themed Death Island last year. Whilst it was incredible in appearance, and explored some novel mechanical ideas, it felt like an oncoming migraine to run. I can’t imagine ever actually picking that up with a group when I could say “Let’s play Death Match” and have us all up and murdering in minutes.

 

PLAY IT? MUST PLAY

Some RPGs are multi-purpose; Death Game does one thing, and it does it perfectly. If you’ve ever desired, deep down, to ruthlessly hunt your friends, please go and see a professional. But maybe play this whilst you’re on the inevitable months-long waiting list for treatment!

TRY THIS IF YOU liked Dead Beats…

…I’m a sucker for art by Hodag, but I’m also keen on anything with a custom system. Death Game is built around steadily shrinking pools of characters, whilst Dead Beats uses a playing-card draw fighting mode to elegantly simulate the madness as you punch your way through hordes of suburban demons.

About Death Game
DesignerLaurie O’Connel
Publisher12 Pins Press
Playcount2-5 Players
AgeAge 14+
Price£35
Contents
  • 132 page Hardback, Map and Zine
RatingMust Play

A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2025.