Critical: Foundation – Season 1 review

Lightning fast sci-fi roleplay with literally zero prep?

Critical: Foundation – Season 1

One problem with roleplaying games is the amount of setup required; learning all the lore, building characters—necessary work to immerse yourself in the world and bring it to life. Sometimes that’s fun, but it can be daunting, especially to people new to the hobby.

Critical: Foundation attempts to shortcut this, with a world, characters and story that are pre-generated and need little to no preparation. Inside the box you get a brief introduction to the world, some nice big character cards and backgrounds, and a set of scenarios ready to run immediately. The creators have taken the approach of a TV series, with 20-30 minute episodes of action; so your players only have to know enough to hold onto a fairly brief burst of narrative at any one time.

So, how well does this work? I’m delighted to say that Critical functions extremely well. I took a group with no awareness of the game whatsoever, explained the setting and basic mechanics, let them choose character cards and backgrounds, and had them thrown into their first episode within 10 minutes. Not just that, but each little scenario is so tightly scripted that we played two in an hour. That’s right, we started a roleplay game from scratch and played two sessions in just over an hour! To those of you who have spent two hours just in character creation, there’s clearly something special here.

The system uses a very simple system with a custom d12 that is numbered from 0-3, and one side with a “X”. I’m always partial to custom dice, and the One Ring RPG comes to mind here, with the eye of Sauron emblazoned on one side of the D12. Rolling the X is a critical failure, but gets players a hero token that lets them add a custom d8 to a future roll. Simply add any skill success boosts to the roll, and see if you meet the difficult number. One criticism is that the skills allocation seem a little arbitrary—why is “Know How” under “Dexterity” rather than “Mental”—but otherwise the system stays out of your way whilst being totally intuitive.

The underlying Critical setting is set in 2035, with a reasonably dystopian evolution of our world. The players take on investigative strike force commandos, sent on missions around the globe by the enigmatic Icarus organisation. Each session, like a high action TV show, involves a new situation that needs resolution. Without too many spoilers, in one the PCs have to raid a military base to find and neutralise a secret weapon, in another they track down a witness whilst trying to escape an ambush.

The elephant in the room here is railroading; forcing players to play exactly one route and one mission. No bones about it; Critical has minimal branching to it’s narrative. Yet, to my surprise, that didn’t seem to be a big problem. I played a game of MÖRK BORG last week and my players spent 2 hours fighting bears in some holes in the ground before they even got onto the first sentence of the adventure I had planned, you can see why I might be concerned. Success here is partly due to Critical’s rapid time-frame*,* which means players focus on solving the problem in front of them, rather than going on massive detours. I actually ran a 30 minute timer in our early adventures, pushing them to quick decisions and focused play. PCs can only take two wounds also, driving a further caution and focus on playing the game at hand

I could talk about limitations, but actually, in a game with such a clear structure to it, many of those limitations are features. Ultimately, the biggest issue is that this box is a one-off play; your group will work through the story and can never play it again; that’s where the Season 2 mini expansion comes in, and the Sanctuary fantasy variant. I was initially sceptical here, but Critical won me over: an adrenaline-laced near-instant role playing experience for anyone.

 

PLAY IT? MUST PLAY

Truly zero prep roleplaying in the near future? Critical: Foundation is a fast, fluid and fun system that delivers exactly what it promises on the tin. If you need a totally trustworthy stepping stone to beginner RPG? This is it.

TRY THIS IF YOU liked Pandemic Legacy: Season One…

…Did your gaming group enjoy working as a team to save the world? Critical: Foundation is a further step away from the two dimensional narrative of board games, but with plenty of guard rails to support you.

About Critical: Foundation – Season 1
DesignerYohan Lemonnier & Kristoff Valla
PublisherHachette
Playcount1-4 Players
AgeAge 14+
Price£35
Contents
  • 4 Character cards
  • 8 Background cards
  • 19 Equipment cards
  • 34 Episode cards
  • 8 non-player Character cards
  • 10 Clue cards
  • 8 Wound cards
  • 15 Status cards
  • 4 Name cards
  • 32 Narrative tokens
  • 4 Hero tokens
  • 5 Clue tokens
  • 7 dice
  • 1 dry-erase marker
  • 1 Building plan
  • 1 Gamemaster screen
  • 9 Episode sheets
  • What is an RPG booklet
  • 1 Season 1 synopsis booklet
  • 1 rulebook
RatingMust Play

 

A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2023.