City Explorer: Kyoto review

A whistlestop tour of urban Japan.

City Explorer: Kyoto is a small box Japanese card game; a rich world of minimalist gaming that still hasn’t made much of a splash in the UK. There are some fantastic, tiny titles like Hatsuden and Koi Koi that it’s frankly a crime we don’t see more of over here. Attempting to bridge that gap, City Explorer is an export by the Taiwanese game company Moaideas.

Setup is simple, setting out rows and columns of cards, the exact number of which vary based on player count. Each round two cards are turned face up, slowly increasing the total amount of information available to all players. On your turn you can either turn over cards and take a look, returning them back in face down position, or you can shift cards up or down rows changing.

At any point a player can choose, instead of looking at or moving cards, to claim an entire row. In that situation they stop taking actions until everyone else has claimed a row; then the game ends. The only change to this is 2 player games which are set up like a 4 player game, each player claiming two rows instead of one. There players carry on taking actions until they’ve claimed both their rows.

Once rows are claimed, play is over and it’s time to award points: there are 5 suits, numbered from 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9, each with the corresponding number of cards available. At the end of the game, the player who holds the most cards in any suit gains a number of points equal to the suit’s value. This takes a moment to understand – in most games rarity increases value – but in City Explorer it is harder to have the most cards in a set of 9 than 5, so the reward is greater.

Alongside this, cards have a range of icons, some (”Teiban”) giving a single point, whilst others (”Oshare”) grant 5 points when collected in sets of three. Draws in suit collection are settled by a tie breaker with the “Tsu” icon.

So it’s collecting some cards for points? What makes City Explorer stand out from a thousand other games? Well, it’s extremely fast! One of our two-person games lasted only slightly longer than it took to count points, as a player claimed a row in each of the first two rounds. Certainly there are very few full games out there that can be finished in the same time as a hand of poker.

Unfortunately that speed is also its limitation. There’s potentially room for lots of tactics and set collection; except that there’s no time to do this because at any point a player will claim a row. The game is thus getting the briefest glimpse of which row might be best and then grabbing it. It almost never passes three or four rounds.

There’s something rather great here, but it needed more playtesting, as unfortunately everything is squashed by the sheer panic of choosing a row before the good ones all go. For example, one of the potential player actions is to shift a card up or down a row, but if any face up cards move, its too obvious which row a player is attempting to increase in value. I had hoped things might be different in the two player game, but its fundamentally the same as with higher counts; the extra row to claim does very slightly change the pacing, but not enough.

The graphic design is from the TANSAN design group, with cards illustrated by Arthur Deussen; I thought they were fine; nice, but also didn’t particularly stand out. I did think the inclusion of both English and Japanese text was excellent without either getting in the way, but even so, I wouldn’t call this a pretty game. A similar conclusion can be made on the gameplay: it is fun at least, but much less than it could have been.

 

PLAY IT? MAYBE

Do you love Kyoto? Do you love lightning-length games that can be played multiple times in 20 minutes? This game could be everything you’ve dreamed of.

TRY THIS IF YOU liked Splendor…

…There’s some very similar DNA in Splendor’s set collection, but if you find that it drags on a bit too long, City Explorer will some of the same ground for you in 5 minutes.

About City Explorer: Kyoto
Designer??(Yuo)
PublisherMoaideas Game Design
Playcount2-5 Players
AgeAge 8+
Price£12
Contents
  • Rulesheet with map of Kyoto
  • Start player card
  • 30 Game cards
RatingMaybe

 

A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2022.