Quartermaster General: East Front review

All Quartermastered on the Eastern Front

On seeing this game, there are broadly going to be two groups of people; those who say “Ah yes, World War Two, okay, I know some stuff about that”; and those who say “Ah, East Front? I wonder if they’ll model the Vernichtungskrieg scorched earth policy properly? – Ooh! What’s their take on tank losses at Prochorovka…?”. In other words, it’s an area that some gamers have an exhaustive level of knowledge, and others don’t.

Quartermaster General is a longstanding series in that vein from Ian Brody, who also created the War of the Ring: Card Game, another game that attracts players with an intense level of subject familiarity. East Front is the first of a new two player head-to-head adaptation of the system.

Players act as Axis or Allies; one player playing as Germany + Axis Pact members and the other as the Soviets, and turns are deceptively simple; on your turn you move your troops, take up to two actions, then take a second move with your tanks and planes (if you have any).

If this sounds limiting, it absolutely is. You literally can’t attack on every front at once; each turn you feel like you barely scratch the surface of what you’d like to do. Thankfully, your opponent suffers from exactly the same limitations.

Cards are an incredibly finite resource too; the maximum you can ever pick up in a turn is three, so burning through five will leave you desperately underresourced in future. Not only that, but when your deck runs out it runs out; potentially no more actions for the rest of the game!

Combat is equally minimalist; attackers declare an attack and the defender immediately loses a piece, unless they have a card to help them. It feels like the opposite of *Risk’*s defensive advantage; it ensures that combat always costs something and advances the board state. Just like Stalingrad in 1942, combat is a process of painful attrition; an attacker can continue attacking indefinitely by removing one of their own units, killing another defending unit in the process.

Defenders are able to use the “Reaction” on the bottom of cards to respond to attacks (although the rules don’t make it clear if an attacker can then use “Reactions” to react to the defenders). Reactions are also always a bit worse than the card’s full action. Interesting choices are the hallmark of a good game, and East Front’s “do you take a small positive now but potentially sacrifice something significantly better in the future?” are a great example of this.

The final piece of the puzzle, and one familiar to players of any Quartermaster General game, is “Supply”. As Napoleon (allegedly) said, “an army marches on its stomach”, and so it is true in East Front: if your units don’t have a clear supply route back to a major city at the end of a turn, then you remove them from the board. In a game where you might only have five units in play, such casual losses are absolutely brutal.

It does mean, however, that the game state of the board will be immediately obvious to some, which frustratingly opaque to others. I had to keep re-explaining supply to my opponent. Supply is blocked by enemy troops adjacent to empty spaces you otherwise control – this is a kicker; I can see lots of objections being raised by unfortunate, less experienced gamers.

East Front is an excellent game, but its biggest contention is its rewards for knowledge of the European theatre of operations in the 40s. Much like Twilight Struggle or War of the Ring, knowledge of the grand shape of events is important for optimum play. If you love the historical context, you will be rewarded; alternatively, if you aren’t particularly interested in WW2, this may feel like being forced to re-enact a very specific conflict again and again rather than the freedom of something more freeform.

 

PLAY IT? YES

If you like mechanically-simple-but-tactically-rich war games, this is be one of the best out there. The lightweight rules hide a deceptively deep experience that will satisfy and frustrate you just the right amount.

TRY THIS IF YOU liked Votes For Women…

…Two games where simplicity belies the struggle beneath, and both a huge development from the fiddly wargames mechanics of previous decades. Pared to the bone, and all the better for it.

About Quartermaster General: East Front
DesignerIan Brody
PublisherAres Games
Playcount2 Players
AgeAge 12+
Price£60
Contents
  • 1 Rulebook
  • 1 Gameboard
  • 56 Soviet cards
  • 54 Axis cards
  • 26 Soviet wooden pieces
  • 29 Axis wooden pieces
  • 25 Cardboard tokens
  • 2 Player aid sheets
RatingYes

 

A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2023.