The End Of The Road
Words by Chris Lowry
Encapsulate started back in issue ##, looking at the cream of the crop of each year’s developments in the world of gaming. We began back in the distant days of #19xx and have now travelled all the way to the last year!
This is sadly the last outing for this feature, but if we have to stop, 2023 was a whirlwind of a year to end on! Still reeling from the crazy post-lockdown postal surges of 2022, several prolific gaming companies sunk under the weight of unforeseen expenses; most notably Holy Grail Games, the creators of Rallyman: GT and Dominations. Others companies like Blacklist Games, deeply invested in the ongoing momentum of running multiple crowdfunding campaigns one after another, went quiet and stopped responding to requests for updates.
It was also the first year where AI Art began to truly impact on the mainstream, with Stronghold Games causing controversy as they chose to use AI-generated art for the latest multi-million dollar Terraforming Mars expansion. The true crown though, for the year’s shooting-yourself-in-the-foot award, goes to Wizards of the Coast for their disastrous attempt to update the Open Gaming License, which caused a huge backlash and potentially harmed the D&D brand forever.

Earthborne Rangers
Earthborne Rangers is an exploration card game, with a deck of rangers and card play based around stats, events and a world that you discover through play. It sits on the shoulders of games like the 1500 card behemoth 7th Continent, open-world video games like Zelda: Breath of the Wild and more than a little on the limitless imaginative horizons of roleplaying games.
Earthborne Games deserve bonus points for their mission to create a locally produced and sustainable game, with FSC-certified wooden tokens and dice, and no plastic at all! Their Kickstarter initially funded in 2021 with over 4,700 backers, but the additional design constraints added some inevitable delays, hence it only appearing on our shelves two years later. Such is the cost of making a game that is fully compostable.
Board games toe a perilous line when it comes to narrative. There’s a certain degree of creative hand-holding they are expected to provide, a railroad of story that players expect to be fed to them. RPGs are free of this constraint; Earthborne Rangers probably comes the closest to a middle ground I’ve seen. It feels truly open world, even to the degree that some events happen around players, rather than to them. Does it lack a little on providing a “win” state? Perhaps, but the wide landscape of exploring a world, and inhabiting it as your own, is a reward worth that cost.

Dorfromantik
Not everything this year was vast and complicated. 2023 also brought us the delightfully relaxed Dorfromantik. Based on the equally chilled computer game from 2019, this is a co-operative tile-laying game where you score points with calm collection of groups. How you build your forests, villages, streams and railway tracks will impact on your ability to multiply your scoring chances.
As the placid accompaniment to its serene gameplay, Dorfromantik is aesthetically pleasing – just putting down the tiles to build a little world is a delight. The slice of cosy countryside these hexagons will leave on your kitchen table is worth the price of admission. For replayability, there are even some light legacy-style elements in the shape of some TOP SECRET boxes that include new ways to score; although there’s no stickers here or permanent changes to pieces.
Dorfromantic managed to swipe the prized Spiel des Jahres Game of the Year award for 2023 – partly because its a great family game that’s also supremely solo-friendly. It’s definitely not built to appeal to serious gamers looking for competitive confrontation, but as a casual distraction, or to play whilst waiting for other things to begin? Difficult to go wrong, and a 7.7 rating on Board Game Geek implies it has left plenty of gamers pretty satisfied.

Votes for Women
There’s the mechanics of an old school war game underneath this snappy-looking two person game. One player represents the American women’s suffragist movement, the other the grumpy oppressive establishment. Fast paced play couples with asymmetric goals and abilities – years of razor-edged games like Root and Oath have paved the way for map seizing warfare that isn’t a 13 hour Risk marathon.
If anything, Votes for Women immediately brings to mind the classic Cold War re-enactment Twilight Struggle, but manages to cover similar ground in a vastly more accessible manner. It would be possible to play without knowing any of the relevant history, but players will find themselves becomes educated, inexorably, through interaction with this excellent piece of design.
Lauded by voices across the review-o-sphere, and voted one of the top games of the year by Polygon and Smithsonian magazine, it’s certainly the tightest blend of historical simulation and fun we encountered during 2023. The production particularly stands out, with the wooden voting checks and cross marks both thematically perfect, and a tactile treasure in the fingers. The first edition sold out completely, and a new Kickstarter reprint will likely be nearing completing when you read this.

Frosthaven
Discussion of 2023 wouldn’t be complete without a mention of Frosthaven. We even featured it in the previous year too, although it only arrived in gamers hands in 2023. The big – with the emphasis on “massive” – sibling to 2019’s Gloomhaven, Frosthaven is best described as more. More adventures, more frost, more systems, more content, more cost and much more box. Its the only game I’ve ever seen that it would not be silly to suggest using a wheelbarrow to manoeuvre around. It weighs 16 kg, around the same as my labrador.
So what, exactly, is it? It’s the most ambitious legacy game ever devised, a sprawling co-operative adventure with entertaining combat and detailed, satisfying character development. Set in the same world as Gloomhaven, you play as mercenaries in a small outpost north of capital city White Oak. Battling through harsh weather and invasion from forces like the Algox – weird mountain yetis – and Lurkers – sentient sea crabs, you will explore the world, live through the seasons, and aim to complete your character’s story arcs and lead them into retirement.
Throughout play the map, cards and other elements are upgraded using a barrage of stickers. These adjustments permanently change the world in which you are roaming. Does it technically mean that this is a £200 single-use game? Not really; especially given that you can download fan made sticker charts to keep your game pieces in pristine condition. Regardless of reusability, Frosthaven certainly represents a huge investment in time, money and shelf space! With 83,000 backers on a $13 million Kickstarter campaign, so far it hasn’t picked up many awards – although maybe that’s just because it’ll take another 10 years to finish playing it through – but it certainly made a huge splash in the world gaming community last year.
