Some fantasy aspirations involve dragons, wizards and chainmail; others are more humble in origin; the realms of cute mice welding buttons and doing rather a lot of scurrying. From the same genre-corner as Redwall and Mouse Guard comes Hickory Dickory; a board game based around the well-known nursery rhyme and the timepiece at its heart; “The mice run up the clock…”
Each player controls five adorable wooden mice, who must scamper around the numbers on a clock face, taking trips on the minute hand and aiming to collect chunky acrylic tiles to deliver for rewards. Play takes place on a huge representation of a working clock; and there’s no denying that Hickory Dickory has a real table presence. There’s a huge cardboard clock face with moveable plastic minute and hour hands, with a chain board that sits underneath with the clock weights. The downside of such a visual spread is that it’s massive – only one of the tables I played it on was actually large enough to set it up all together. Thankfully, the chain board can be placed to the side for smaller settings.
Annoyingly, assembling (and disassembling) the clock hands was not a delight at all – I’m a reasonably practical and handy person, but in the end I had to force some plastic and thankfully didn’t break it. This is not the ideal start to interacting with a brand new purchase. A construction guide is included, but I was still terrified about ripping the board in half! Player boards are also made of disappointingly thin cardstock, a strange choice when the overall production value is so high.
The game splits into five rounds, one for each hour from seven o’clock to midnight. On each round the minute hand turns around the clock, allowing mice on the “1” to act, then on “2”, and so on. Mice can activate actions on their number, or jump onto the minute hand to swing round to further actions, making this a rare example of a worker rotation game.
Action order is based on mice position on the clock hand, and then on a shifting colour order between players. If your mouse was the last to jump onto the swinging hand, it’s the first to act on the next number. Adding to the challenge there is limited space on the hand; if too many mice jump on earlier rodents are pushed off, unceremoniously, and forced to take their action earlier than planned.
A good rulebook covers a range of somewhat unusual concepts; although a few of them don’t quite ring true to the theme painted over them. What are you actually doing when you “deliver” a tile? Why are you placing them on your “hunt” board. Still, clearly explained concepts and iconography help the mechanics fade into the background, allowing you to plan and score as many points as possible.
It’s a shame then, that there’s less game here than one would hope. Your hunt board, filled with 16 spaces that need filling with tiles, is very susceptible to poor luck. The wrong tiles coming out onto the main board, or not getting the opportunity to pick them up can make a difference of tens of points; more than enough to lose you the game. Some limited action Euro games, like Castles of Burgundy, manage to build and grow, a sparse number of choices contributing to a powerful experience; Hickory Dickory never really develops – your actions on turn five can feel much like those on turn one.
The optimum number of players is probably three. With two, player interaction is limited, and we didn’t have a single mice pushed off the hand due to overcrowding. With four, it happened so often as to completely derail planning. Even then, Hickory Dickory never really shone for us, despite some lovely elements.
PLAY IT? MAYBE
Unless you have fond memories of a particular nursery rhyme, or fancy trying a few unusual concepts wrapped up in an undeniably satisfying presentation, you might not want to run up this particular clock.
TRY THIS IF YOU liked Tzolk’in…
…Hickory Dickory is in a small genre, but other designers have covered rotational worker placement games too: Tzolk’in has a similarly massive table presence, but complements it with an equally vast depth of choices and crunchy decisions.
| About Hickory Dickory | |
|---|---|
| Designer | Sawyer West |
| Publisher | Plaid Hat Games |
| Playcount | 1-4 Players |
| Age | Age 10+ |
| Price | £66 |
| Contents |
|
| Rating | Maybe |
A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2022.
