Nerds love a ring binder. Of course we do. We curse the fact that we live in this modern age, with smart phones yet – painfully – without Filofaxes. Anything that fills that void in our life is desperately welcome, so when I opened Almanac’s ring bound collection of playboards, I was spellbound.
Almanac: Crystal Peaks is a standalone expansion for the Almanac series of games by Scott Almes – the designer most well known for their Tiny Epic series. Set in the cute fictional world of Baeloria, the game is thematomechanically similar to the first entry Almanac: The Dragon Road, whilst not requiring it to play.
In short, players are traders, meandering their cute little carts full of goods through various places in Baeloria. Each page of the ring-bound almanac is a new location, that features new rules, symbols and tokens thay alter the base mechanics in a gentle but definitive way.
New pages being building entire new game boards is not a completely new idea – Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion took a similar path. In that game the concept was introduced to save on setting up complex map tiles; in Almanac it’s about giving a huge variety of similar-yet-different approaches to the game’s central conceit. In that, it achieves what it sets out to do.
Unfortunately, I’m reminded of Friedemann Friese’s innovative game 504; it offered literally hundreds of combinations of mechanics, all in a single box – but sadly failed to make sure that the created games that were actually fun. Variety is always welcome, but the unaltered core game in Almanac isn’t compelling enough to be worthy of so many iterations. Some pages had novel mechanics that were unbalanced enough to be broken; I won a game entirely due to one page’s opportunity to buy multiple goods cheaply and then sell them at maximum price, repeatedly, whilst no one else was given the same option. Two hours in, that kind of swinginess is frustrating on everyone.
Now, I can accept games that lack perfection in their gameplay when their theme is on point; true immersion in a world can let one make allowances. Unfortunately, some of the writing in Almanac: Crystal Peaks is disappointingly poor; especially the flavour sentences on Encounter cards, which range from inelegant to nonsensical. Even worse, some page explanations of additional rules are unclear; some of my players were already feeling mechanics-memory malaise, and having to regularly home-rule ambiguous wording exacerbated this. The whole project needed a significant line edit – when your players are reliably laughing at the unintentionally clumsy wording each time they draw a card, you know something is wrong.
Even the box exterior managed to score incredibly poorly for useful information. How many players does this game play? How long does it take? I’ve read the manual and played it, and I can tell you the answer is “2-4 players, probably” and “around 2 hours”. There’s no clue to this information on the outside, or even at the start of the rules. I’m actually not sure there isn’t a solo mode I’ve missed somehow. Overall, Almanac: Crystal Peaks has some lovely ideas but lacks the polish I’d expect.
PLAY IT? NO
The box looks intriguing, like a huge hardback book on your shelf; I’d leave it there if I were you.
TRY THIS IF YOU liked Castles of Burgundy…
…An exceptional Euro game that plays 2-4 players; for variability the new edition includes all 10 well thought-out expansions in the box. You’ll definitely have a lot of fun with Castles of Burgundy, but Almanac: Crystal Peaks adds theme and flavour into the mix.
| About Almanac: Crystal Peaks | |
|---|---|
| Designer | Scott Almes |
| Publisher | Kolossal Games |
| Playcount | 2-4 Players |
| Age | Age 12+ |
| Price | £52.49 |
| Contents |
|
| Rating | No |
A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2022.
