Uwe Rosenberg’s Patchwork was somewhat of a sensation back in 2015, at a time where tabletop gaming was starting to push out of male-heavy geek culture and into “normal” people’s lives. It combined a (perhaps) traditionally feminine theme of quilting with an incredibly tight two-player competition. This made a perfect stepping stone for couples that might not have otherwise considered board gaming for them.
Stack ‘n Stuff extends that wide invitation to children and young families. Together, you compete to load a delivery van with “Stack” tiles and earn coins. Go past a coin stop on the board and get more coins! Reach the house at the end of the road, and pay a penalty for empty spaces in your van. Clearly, this is Patchwork Light (in fact, it’s heavily based on the previous title Patchwork Express). Compared to Patchwork, it has a shorter play length, and slightly less mechanics; taking about 90 seconds to teach, compared to its older sibling’s 2 minutes. The main differences are a) less spaces on your player board, b) no bonus reward for completing a 7×7 square block first, c) simpler “Stuff” tiles that are kept back until nearer the end, to make it easier for a player to fill awkward gaps.
I think it achieves everything it sets out to do, but is still a lesser game as a result. It is slightly easier to pick up, and 10 minute play length is shorter than 15 in the original. However I missed the strategic complexity of the 7×7 bonus and the larger board. My main problem is that Patchwork never felt particularly random; I always felt mostly in control of my choices. In Stack ‘N Stuff, the narrower range of tiles and space to fit them means there are moments, much more often, where you just don’t have a tile you want available to you.
The question that needs to be asked, really, is “Did Patchwork need a simpler version”. The age on the box here is 6+, but I’ve played Patchwork with a 4 year old. They weren’t very good at it—#humblebrag I won—but they had fun, and I was able to complete a thoughtful little challenge whilst they enjoyed themselves. Stack ‘N Stuff is probably about as much fun for a 4 year old, but my 6 year old is able to cope with the only-very-slightly-more-difficult rules of the first game, and it’s a lot more fun for me.
PLAY IT? MAYBE
If you’ve never played Patchwork, and you have a 4 year old that you are aching to introduce to board games, Stack N Stuff is for you. Otherwise, I’d pick up the original.
TRY THIS IF YOU LIKED Karuba…
Karuba is an adventure in the jungle, whilst Stack N Stuff is a jaunt in the urban environment, but both involve the inevitable inability to place tiles when and where you want. Karuba is a little more involved, but you also get to pick up shiny gems!
| About Patchwork: Stack ‘n Stuff | |
|---|---|
| Designer | Uwe Rosenberg, Marianne Waage |
| Publisher | Lookout Games |
| Playcount | 2 players |
| Age | 6+ |
| Price | £25 |
| Contents | 1 Time Board 1 Truck 2 player boards 6 boxes 34 coin tiles 2 time tokens 8 stuff tiles 15 stack tiles. |
| Rating | Maybe |
A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2022.