Mythic Bastionland review

Find your Knightly path. Let it forge your future!

Mythic Bastionland 

Mythic Bastionland is the latest RPG from epic designer Chris McDowall. Chris represents a sort of chimeric force within the world of roleplaying design; he takes decades-established concepts and procedures, then studiously ignores them in pursuit of narrative pre-eminence. Into The Odd streamlined mechanics that I thought were impossible to mess with, whilst Electric Bastionland set an incredibly clear vision of how a city should feel without setting any limits at all on what it could be. When McDowall releases a book, I’m always excited, with just a hint of apprehension as to which embedded pieces of design misconceptions are about to get dislodged from my brain.

Mythic Bastionland is a land of Arthurian heraldric adventure. Well, maybe it’s more Arthuri-ish; it certainly takes a far broader approach than simply filing the serial numbers off Excalibur. The Referee creates a hex-map Realm, within which the Knights will roam for a season, aiming to fulfil their Oath; “Seek the Myths; Honour the Seers; Protect the Realm”.

Since play pivots almost entirely around the Players’ Knights and the Myths of the Realm, it’s appropriate that 80% of the pages are variations of Knight types; such as “The Amber Knight” who carries an amulet of blazing heat, or “The Moat Knight” who fights best waist-deep in water; and Myths; such as “The Bat”, perpetrator of crime-sprees, or “The Hole”, a deep cavern, peopled by the Holfolk. Each Realm will contain six or so “Myths”; story-threaded ideas that are deeply envisioned within the book, whilst also being loose enough to fit with any emerging narrative at the table.

As a physical release, Mythic Bastionland is a satisfying and appealing A4 book. Layout is clear, Alec Sorensen’s art is lovely, and even the index is useful, if a little sparse. Nearly every page has some sort of random table for sparking ideas; and the basic mechanics for combat and dice rolling are clearly explained early on. A quick reference spread would have been a help, although I think most rules are revealed through character creation and initial play.

The key concept that ties the book together is “Primacy of Action”; the idea that things that have already occurred take priority over new events in a game. It’s typical McDowall stuff; purposeful, elegant in its simplicity… and a little bit tricky to get your head round. The purpose is clear: Mythic Bastionland is a game of shared world-building in a setting of mythological uncertainty. It would be so easy for everything to feel untethered and open to interpretation. Primacy of Action means that the Knights’ journeys are the counterpoint to this looseness; their grandiose adventures of derry-do are unequivocally true and become the lens through which the future is defined. Character progression is measured in points of Glory; a mechanical reward for unravelling the Omens within nebulous Myths and stapling them into your own legend.

Are Seers evil? Are Myths random outbursts of untamed wild magicks, or part of some sinister plan laid down by “The Silk Knight”? What happened in the in-game century that passed between sessions? The beauty of Mythic Bastionland is that—within the conceptual framework provided—everything else is up for grabs. Chris has provided one of the most intriguing tutorial sections I’ve ever read: thirty pages of “Play” and “Thoughts”, where he provides an example of play, then critiques and praises the approach that the fictional Referee has taken. He’s much more interested in the form than the function, whilst also acknowledging that the nuts and bolts of interaction at the table are how both come to life.

I’ll end with a note of caution; so much of Mythic Bastionland is intentionally free-form that running it may be a daunting undertaking. As a seasoned GM, I had to leap wholeheartedly into uncertain waters, making up solutions and rulings on the fly. If you’ve only played spoon-fed RPG, or never played at all, that might be a fault. I encourage you to push on regardless of getting it “right”: in- and out-of-game, the path you tread together is the foundation for your future.

 

PLAY IT? MUST PLAY

Another slam-dunk from the creator of Into The Odd; Mythic Bastionland covers new ground, always impressive in the intensely creative world of TTRPG. In some ways it holds your hand better than any other game out there, in other ways you are left to your own devices. If you can figure it out—much like removing an immovable sword from a magical rock—your stories will be legendary.

TRY THIS IF YOU liked Inevitable…

…Inevitable feels more like the scene-by-scene play of Fiasco, whereas Mythic Bastionland is undeniably an OSR game of dice-and-damage: but both put the mythology of your world on centre stage. Whilst Inevitable provides a vast amount of lore and asks you to learn it all, Mythic expects you to make everything up yourself; choose your potion wisely.

About Mythic Bastionland
DesignerChris McDowall
PublisherBastionland Press
Playcount1-4 Players
AgeAge 14+
Price£50
Contents
  • 210 Pages A4 Hardback
RatingMust Play

 

A review written for Tabletop Gaming Magazine. Magazine page copyright to TTG Magazine 2025.